Tag Archive | chicken

AGOA : Parliament this week 3 Nov 2015

cropped-sa-parliament-2.jpg

 

Editorial…….

AGOA : What and who to believe….

Reported to clients 5 November……On June 10 2015, a meeting took place in Parliament between the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) and the Portfolio Committee on Trade and Industry, chaired by Ms. Joanna Fubbs, during which DTI was reporting back on its progress with B-BBEE.

The meeting was interrupted by the appearance of Faizel Ismail, the special SA Trade Ambassador to thefaisel ismail AGOA talks, who dramatically made an announcement with the Chair’s agreement despite nothing on the agenda, to all members of the Committee. To sum up the statement he said that the negotiations on the AGOA trade agreement could be considered a success. There was considerable joy amongst MPs generally.

Then on September 8, Lionel October, Director General of the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), surely “Mr. Big” when it comes to knowledge of trade relationships and policy with other countries, made the following rather obtuse statement to the PC on Trade and Industry when asked for the current position with regard to the AGOA.

He answered, “As for SA’s US relationship, no one relationship would save SA. The US has decided to re-industrialise with an emphasis on energy development in Africa after a previous emphasis on the service industry. The AGOA had been reviewed, and meat trade issues needed to be resolved but in general the AGOA had grown in its relationships.”

What this was supposed to mean was difficult to interpret. But then discussions were on-going at the time between SA representatives and the US congress over poultry, meat and pork issues and relationships were admittedly difficult. Dumping by the US was the accusation. Lack of certification of SA exports was the reply. Most were downcast.

The context

The occasion for DG October’s remark was DTI’s presentation of its annual report to Parliament, with Minister Rob Davies present, and it was in answer to an Opposition member on the subject. It was apparent to all at the time that the AGOA had not been mentioned as one of the “achievements” of DTI for the year 2014/5 and the first quarter of the present year. That’s as close as Parliament can get to being up-to-date.

Then newspapers announced that South Africa’s inclusion had been agreed to by Congress and the AGOA Bill had been sent to President Obama for signature. The poultry and meat issue had been resolved apparently.

lionel october 3Everybody relaxed and Lionel October told Parliament in a further PC Trade and Industry meeting, this time on the Protection of Investment Bill, that indeed the Bill had indeed gone for signature and all was done and dusted.

Reverse gear

The we heard from the media, not DTI, that everything is held up again after DTI had admitted under pressure that they had failed to meet a poultry declaration deadline under the AGOA. A war of words started on whose fault that was, DTI claiming that the fault was mutual between the US and South Africa.

In the meanwhile we had put the AGOA behind us, the focus having shifted in the meanwhile to watching the Portfolio Committees of Police and awaiting the return of Private Security Industry Bill, President Zuma staying “mum” on the subject and the Cabinet saying nothing in their regular statements from GCIS.

Clearly the preamble to the AGOA agreement had fallen foul with the US Constitution finding this particular Bill objectionable in terms of international obligations on expropriation, presumably connecting AGOA to US investments in the security sector industry where US owned interests stood to lose control of their investments in South Africa. This time it was the US media reporting, not the negotiating parties.

Just recently, Ms. Joanna Fubbs, chairperson of the Trade and Industry Committee, refused Oppositionjoan fubbs members the right to discuss the issue of the Private Security Industry Bill in her Committee, stating that the subject matter was the domain of another Committee. The subject at the time was the Protection of Investment Bill, now passed at committee level, and whether this Bill would contribute further to poor US relationships, as was apparent with the Security Industry Bill already.

 Passing the cushion

But that was not the full truth. The PC Committee on Police, as far as we can establish, has never discussed in depth the implications of the Private Security Industry Bill as far as the AGOA is concerned. Meanwhile President Zuma, who had the Bill and still has, must be perfectly aware of the implications as must the whole Cabinet, since it is not just the poultry industry that is affected but the security industry, the automotive industry and a whole lot more.

This is especially in the light of the fact that, according to reports, this Bill has been mentioned in Congress in front of the SA Ambassador called to Congress to answer on the subject. Nobody knows therefore, if Parliament will again verbalise on the Bill because nobody will come clean on why the Private Security Industry Bill is stuck where it is in the Presidential office.

 AGOA vs Security Bill

Is AGOA on the altar of ideology, one must ask therefore.

courtesy iol

courtesy iol

During a very recent briefing to the PC on Trade and Industry on AGOA progress, Minister Davies told parliamentarians that everything “was in the hands of veterinarians, both on the US side and in South Africa, both parties taking the issues of animal disease and sickness very seriously“. He continued, “It has been more than we dare do in DTI to interfere or intervene in this process. It is supposed to be an independent process. Avian ‘flu in the US is a repeating disease but, however, all is now resolved from an SA perspective.”

The Minister added, “Furthermore on our side we, the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries and their veterinarians have written to the US side to say we are ready to implement all conditions so President Obama can sign. All the deals are done in both the US and SA industries and we just await the US response”, he concluded with Faizel Ismail present.

Dave MacPherson (DA) pointed to the fact that the whole of AGOA would be torpedoed anyway if the Private Security Industry Bill were to go through. Minister Davies responded that the Private Security had not come up once in the AGOA talks with the US. “Too much of this has been a media debate”, he said.

Under pressure

Consequently Minister Davies is fully aware the situation but dealing with the issues as if they were not connected, which could be considered slightly disingenuous. It is known that Minister Davies very much wants the AGOA deal signed but Oppositions members conclude, when asked, that they also cannot think of a single reason for pushing through the Private Security Industry Bill if it is at the expense of the AGOA and growth.

Unless it can be put down to disharmony within the Cabinet or intransigence on the part of the Minister of Police, they say.

As for the future of the AGOA then, for the moment don’t hold your breath but rather cross your fingers that Cabinet as a whole will come out of its ideological bubble, if this is the case.

Posted in Facebook and Twitter, Finance, economic, Special Recent Posts, Trade & Industry0 Comments


This website is Archival

If you want your publications as they come from Parliament please contact ParlyReportSA directly. All information on this site is posted two weeks after client alert reports sent out.

Upcoming Articles

  1. Carbon Tax debate heats up in Parliament
  2. Copyright Bill goes into final stages
  3. Hate Crimes Bill on way back to Parliament
  4. DTI briefs Parliament on the road ahead
  5. RE-IPP4 alive again with LNG interest
  6. Competition Commission rough on investors

Earlier Editorials

Earlier Stories

  • AARTO licence demerit system studied  …. In what has been a legislative marathon, the update of the Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Offences Act (AARTO) has now reached a stage […]

  • SARS role at border posts being clarified …. In adopting the Border Management Authority (BMA) Bill, Parliament’s Portfolio Committee on Home Affairs agreed with a wording that at all future one-stop border […]

  • Modernising SAPO a culture change ….. sent to clients 27 February…. Stage by stage, Mark Barnes, Group Chief Executive Officer of South African Post Office (SAPO), appears to be reforming cultures and […]

  • OECD money task force waiting for SA   ….sent to clients Feb 7…. Chairperson of the Standing Committee on Finance, Yunus Carrim, made it quite clear in terms of parliamentary rules that […]

  • President Zuma vs Parliament on FICA Bill …..editorial……The convoluted thinking that is taking place in South Africa to avoid the consequences of the law has once again become evident in […]